Why is my Symfony route not working?
When you register a new controller in Symfony and immediately hit a 404 Not Found, it usually feels like a routing configuration error. However, as shown in your specific case, the issue often stems from how the framework discovers routes, not necessarily what is inside your routing.yml file. You deleted an existing bundle (Acme) and created a new one (MyBlogBundle) with a controller decorated with the @Route annotation. Despite this, running php app/console router:debug reveals no route matching /, only internal profiler paths.
This behavior indicates a disconnect between your controller definition and the routing configuration system. The root cause lies in the fact that your routing.yml file under MyBlogBundle/Resources/config/routing.yml is empty. In modern Symfony versions (2.x through 4.x), while annotations on controllers can define routes, they often require specific conditions to be picked up correctly by the router without additional configuration.
In older Symfony 2 projects, especially those using the legacy routing system where routing.yml was explicitly loaded via a resource mapping in app/config/routing.yml, simply adding an annotation to a controller was not always enough if the bundle structure wasn't aligned with how the router scans for routes. The @Route attribute is powerful, but it relies on the router being configured to scan the bundle's route resources.
Looking at your app/config/routing.yml:
my_blog:
resource: "@MyBlogBundle/Resources/config/routing.yml"
prefix: /
This configuration tells Symfony to load routing definitions from that specific file. Since that file is empty, Symfony loads nothing from it. It then looks for routes defined via annotations, but the mechanism for picking up annotated routes depends on your application's bootstrap configuration and whether you are using the legacy or newer routing loaders.
If you are strictly relying on the @Route annotation without defining a resource in the bundle-specific routing file, you might be encountering a mismatch between how Symfony 2 handles bundles versus later versions. In many Symfony 2 setups, if you do not define a route resource within your bundle and rely solely on annotations, the router may fail to register them unless you explicitly enable the annotation scanning or ensure the bundle is properly registered in the application kernel.
To resolve this, you have two primary paths depending on your Symfony version and desired architecture:
Explicitly define the route in
routing.yml: Move away from relying solely on annotations for routing if you are on an older Symfony setup. Define the route directly in the file referenced by your main routing config:# MyBlogBundle/Resources/config/routing.yml my_blog_home: path: / defaults: { _controller: MyBlogBundle:Main:index }This ensures the route is unambiguously registered regardless of annotation scanning issues.
Enable Annotation Scanning: If you prefer to keep using annotations, ensure your
app/config/routing.ymlincludes a line to scan for annotated routes in your bundles. For example:_annotations: trueOr, depending on your specific Symfony 2 version and kernel configuration, ensure that the annotation reader is correctly instantiated during the bootstrap process.
Another critical detail often overlooked in Symfony 2 is the location of the controller class relative to the bundle namespace. Your controller is defined as namespace My\BlogBundle\Controller;. While this matches the typical convention, the routing configuration must point to the exact class name or use a valid alias. In your case, using MyBlogBundle:Main:index in the YAML defaults maps the bundle short name (MyBlogBundle) to the controller namespace and action correctly.
If you clear the cache and still see no routes, verify that your bundle is actually loaded by checking the kernel configuration or running php app/console debug:bundle. If the bundle isn't registered in the kernel, the controller won't be instantiated, and consequently, no route will be found.
Finally, consider migrating to Symfony 3 or 4 if you are still maintaining a Symfony 2 codebase with legacy routing quirks. These versions introduced significant improvements to how routes are discovered via attributes and annotations, reducing the likelihood of such configuration mismatches. For instance, in Symfony 4, defining a route attribute on a controller method is often sufficient without needing explicit routing.yml entries for simple internal resources, provided the framework's service container is configured to scan for them.