PHP Setting a Session Cookie with SameSite
The session_set_cookie_params function has evolved significantly over recent PHP versions, but adding the SameSite attribute requires specific attention to parameter order and type. Your proposed implementation attempts to pass "Lax" as the sixth argument directly into session_set_cookie_params. While the intent is correct, this approach relies on a version-specific behavior that may not be compatible with your current environment or future upgrades.
In PHP 7.3 and later, the function signature was updated to accept an additional parameter for the SameSite attribute. However, it is crucial to understand that this argument expects a string literal, not necessarily a variable holding a string value in all contexts, though passing a string like "Lax" works if the version supports it. The critical issue lies in the fact that you do not have PHP 7.3 installed yet. Passing an extra parameter to a function when the underlying C extension expects fewer arguments results in a runtime error or unexpected behavior depending on how the Zend Engine handles variadic arguments in your specific build.
To implement SameSite="Lax" correctly without upgrading immediately, you must ensure the PHP build supports the new signature. If your current version is 7.2 or earlier, adding that sixth parameter will likely cause a fatal error because the function definition does not expect it. The correct way to set this attribute in modern supported versions (PHP 7.3+) involves passing the value as a string constant or variable at the end of the argument list:
session_set_cookie_params(
$cookie_timeout,
$cookieParams["path"],
$cookie_domain,
$session_secure,
$cookie_httponly,
"Lax"
);
Notice that the value "Lax" is passed as a string. You might see discussions suggesting Cookie::SAMESITE_LAX, but that constant belongs to the PHP session cookie helper classes introduced in even newer versions (PHP 8.2+). For backward compatibility and standard usage, passing the string "Lax" or "Strict" directly is the standard approach for PHP 7.3 through 8.x.
Implementation Trade-offs
When introducing SameSite attributes, you are fundamentally changing how browsers handle cross-site requests involving your session cookies. Setting it to "Lax" allows cookies to be sent with top-level navigational requests but blocks them from being sent with cross-site POST requests and some form submissions unless explicitly allowed via CSRF tokens. This is a significant security improvement that mitigates Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) vulnerabilities without completely breaking user experience, as it still permits navigation between domains.
However, there are pitfalls to consider when migrating existing applications. If you enable SameSite globally via session_set_cookie_params, you must audit your application's CSRF protection mechanisms. Relying solely on the cookie attribute is insufficient for modern security standards; you should implement a robust CSRF token verification process in your forms. Without tokens, enabling SameSite=Lax or SameSite=Strict might inadvertently block legitimate cross-site interactions if your frontend relies on third-party widgets that send POST requests to your endpoints.
Another consideration is the interaction with other session parameters. The order of arguments in session_set_cookie_params is rigid: timeout, path, domain, secure, httponly, and finally samesite (in PHP 7.3+). Shuffling these or omitting the samesite parameter when you intend to set it will result in the attribute being omitted entirely from the cookie header. Always verify your PHP version's specific function signature before adding arguments.
If you are using a framework like Laravel, managing session cookies is often abstracted away. In such cases, configuring same_site within the session configuration array is preferred over manually calling session_set_cookie_params, as frameworks handle the parameter ordering and serialization automatically. This ensures consistency across environments and reduces the risk of misconfiguration when upgrading PHP versions.