Using a try/catch with cURL in PHP

Using a try/catch with cURL in PHP

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 4 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

Why curl_exec Returns Empty Instead of Throwing in PHP

When attempting to validate a third-party resource that may switch between operational and maintenance states, relying solely on HTTP status codes is often insufficient. The scenario described involves checking a file containing either "true" or "false". If the file exists and contains "true", the application routes traffic to one URL; if it is missing, empty, or explicitly says "false", it routes elsewhere. A common misconception in this context is that network failures or timeouts will automatically trigger an exception within a try/catch block.

In your implementation, you have configured CURLOPT_FAILONERROR to true. This option instructs cURL to throw exceptions only for HTTP status codes between 400 and 599. However, this setting does not cover network-level failures such as DNS resolution failures, connection timeouts, or SSL handshake errors that occur when the server is unreachable. Furthermore, because you have set CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER to true, cURL is designed to return the response body as a string rather than printing it directly.

The critical issue lies in how cURL handles transient network errors when CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER is active. Instead of throwing an exception immediately upon failure, cURL often captures the error and returns an empty string (or a string containing the error message if CURLOPT_ERRORBUFFER is used). Consequently, your code executes $fb = curl_exec($curl);, receives an empty string, and proceeds to the logic check. Since an empty string does not equal "true" or "false", the variable $response remains as initialized ("false"), which might seem correct logically but masks the underlying network failure.

To properly distinguish between a successful read of "false", a missing file returning an empty response, and a complete server outage, you must handle both the return value and the error state explicitly. You need to check if cURL encountered an error before attempting to parse the response body.

The most robust approach involves checking curl_errno() or retrieving the error message via curl_error(). This allows you to separate application logic (the file content) from infrastructure issues (connection failures). Here is a refined implementation that addresses the behavior observed on both IIS and Unix systems:

$options = [
    CURLOPT_URL => 'https://[domain]/test.htm',
    CURLOPT_PORT => 443,
    CURLOPT_FRESH_CONNECT => true,
    CURLOPT_FOLLOWLOCATION => false,
    CURLOPT_FAILONERROR => true,
    CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER => true,
    CURLOPT_TIMEOUT => 10,
    CURLOPT_SSL_VERIFYPEER => true, // Recommended for production security
];

$fb = "";
$response = "false";

try {
    $curl = curl_init();
    curl_setopt_array($curl, $options);

    // Execute the request
    $fb = curl_exec($curl);

    // Check for cURL errors even if CURLOPT_RETURNTRANSFER is true
    $curlErrno = curl_errno($curl);
    
    if ($curlErrno) {
        // Handle network failures (DNS, timeout, connection refused)
        throw new Exception("cURL Error: " . curl_error($curl), $curlErrno);
    }

    curl_close($curl);

} catch (Exception $e) {
    // This block catches both custom exceptions and cURL errors thrown above
    // If the server is offline, we do not want to throw a generic "Invalid URL" exception
    // that hides the real reason for failure. Instead, we treat it as an unavailable state.
    
    if ($e->getCode() === CURLE_OPERATION_TIMEDOUT || $e->getMessage() === 'Connection timed out') {
        // Specific handling for timeouts or unreachability
        // Keep $response as "false" to trigger the failover URL
    } else {
        throw new Exception("Invalid URL", 0, $e);
    }
}

// Logic to determine final response
if ($fb === "true") {
    $response = "true";
} elseif ($fb === "") {
    // File exists but is empty or returned a blank string
    $response = "false"; 
} else {
    // Explicitly handles cases where the content is not true/false
    // But given requirements, we treat anything other than 'true' as a failover candidate
    if (!in_array(trim($fb), ['true', 'false'])) {
         $response = "false"; // Or handle invalid content specifically
    } else {
        $response = $fb;
    }
}

echo '<p class="response1">' . htmlspecialchars($response) . '</p>';

// If cURL was successful, $response is determined. 
// If an exception was thrown (e.g., DNS failure), the script might need to catch it here 
// or let it bubble up depending on error handling requirements.
echo '<p class="response3">' . htmlspecialchars($response) . '</p>';

Handling Third-Party Failover Logic

The core challenge in your specific case is that a third-party server may simply stop responding (timeout) or return an empty body during maintenance, rather than returning a 503 status code. The original code assumed that any deviation from the expected "true" string meant a failover was needed.

By separating the curl_errno check, you gain visibility into why the request failed. If curl_exec returns an empty string without triggering an error code, it usually means the HTTP request succeeded (200 OK), but the body is empty. In your logic, this should be treated as "false" to trigger the failover URL. However, if curl_exec triggers a cURL error (like CURLE_OPERATION_TIMEDOUT), you must decide whether to treat this as an immediate failover or retry the request.

In many high-availability architectures, treating a hard network timeout as a signal to switch endpoints is safer than waiting indefinitely. The code above demonstrates how to capture these distinct states without masking them with generic exceptions. This ensures that your application behaves predictably regardless of whether the server is IIS-based or running on Linux, provided the PHP version supports the standard cURL extensions correctly.

For projects built on the Laravel framework, similar patterns exist using the Http facade, where you can access the $response->getStatusCode() and $response->getBody() to achieve the same separation of concerns, ensuring that network failures are explicitly handled before checking business logic content.

Our network