MySQL Select Statement, WHERE 'IN' Clause

MySQL Select Statement, WHERE 'IN' Clause

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 3 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

The Hidden Pitfall of String-Based IN Clauses in MySQL

A common misconception when querying data in MySQL involves how the IN operator interacts with string columns versus numeric ones. Consider a scenario where you have a course_data table with a user_id and a days column. In this specific case, user_id is stored as a VARCHAR, but it contains comma-separated values like 1,3,5. When you attempt to filter rows based on whether a specific day (e.g., 1) exists within that string using a standard IN clause, the behavior often contradicts expectations.

If your goal is to exclude users who have a specific day listed in their comma-separated column, a query like this usually fails to behave as intended:

SELECT usrID, usrFirst, usrLast, usrEmail
FROM tblUsers
WHERE usrID NOT IN (
    SELECT users.usrID
    FROM `course_data` courses
    JOIN `tblUsers` users ON courses.user_id = users.usrID -- Prefer explicit JOIN syntax
    WHERE days IN ('$day')
)
GROUP BY usrID
ORDER BY usrID;

The core issue lies in how MySQL evaluates the condition days IN ('$day'). When $day is set to "1", the database engine checks if the string stored in the days column is exactly equal to the string "1". It does not perform a substring search or a split operation. Therefore, if a row contains "1,3,5", it will not match "1". The entire comma-separated string must be identical to the variable provided for the condition to evaluate as true. This is why passing $day = "1" returns no results matching that specific row, while passing $day = "1,3,5" successfully matches the full string content.

To achieve the logic of "does this row contain day 1?", you must explicitly search within the string content. Since days is a VARCHAR, using regular expressions or LIKE operators becomes necessary. A robust approach uses the REGEXP operator with a pattern that matches the day as a standalone entity, ensuring it isn't accidentally matching "1" inside "10".

SELECT usrID, usrFirst, usrLast, usrEmail
FROM tblUsers t
WHERE t.usrID NOT IN (
    SELECT u.usrID
    FROM course_data c
    JOIN tblUsers u ON c.user_id = u.usrID
    WHERE c.days REGEXP '(^|,)1(,|$)'
)
GROUP BY usrID;

In this revised query, the pattern (^|,)1(,|$) ensures that the number 1 is matched only if it appears at the start of the string (^), followed by a comma or end-of-string, or preceded by a comma and followed by an end-of-string. This prevents false positives where 1 might be part of 10.

However, there is a significant trade-off here: storing lists in VARCHAR columns violates database normalization principles. It complicates queries, makes indexing impossible on the days column, and requires complex string manipulation logic for every read operation. If your application relies on this pattern, you are likely dealing with data that should be normalized. Ideally, course_data should have a separate row for each day associated with a user, or the days column should be an integer type if it represents a single value.

If refactoring the schema is not immediately possible, using Laravel Eloquent offers a cleaner syntax to handle these string checks without writing raw SQL every time. You can define a custom accessor or use query builder conditions that encapsulate this regex logic, ensuring your application remains maintainable even with imperfect data structures.

Our network