OpenSSL SSL_connect: SSL_ERROR_SYSCALL in connection to NotMySite.ru:443
When debugging a cURL failure where some proxies work while others fail with OpenSSL SSL_connect: SSL_ERROR_SYSCALL, it is easy to jump straight into disabling security checks. You might be tempted to set CURLOPT_SSL_VERIFYPEER and CURLOPT_SSL_VERIFYHOST to false, or perhaps tweak the SSL version using CURLOPT_SSLVERSION. While these flags address handshake failures related to certificate validation or protocol mismatches, they do not resolve a system call error occurring after the TCP tunnel is established.
The log snippet you are looking at reveals a specific sequence of events. The proxy successfully negotiates the HTTP CONNECT method, returns a 200 Connection established, and hands over the socket. At this precise moment, cURL switches from acting as an HTTP client to performing an SSL handshake directly with the target server (NotMySite.ru). This is where the disconnect happens.
The error message SSL_ERROR_SYSCALL indicates that a system call failed during the SSL connection process. In practical terms, this usually means the remote peer closed the connection unexpectedly or returned invalid data while you were expecting valid SSL handshake records. Since your logs show the proxy replied 200, the issue is not with the proxy itself blocking the traffic; it is likely how the target server at NotMySite.ru handles the incoming connection after the tunnel is formed.
One common culprit in this scenario is a mismatch in TLS versions or cipher suites between the client and the server, specifically when using an HTTP proxy. Even though cURL attempts to negotiate (as seen in the log: ALPN, offering h2, Cipher selection: ALL...), older servers running on legacy hardware might reject newer protocols like TLS 1.2 or TLS 1.3, or they might not support the specific cipher suites your PHP environment is configured to use by default.
If you have already tried disabling verification flags without success, you should investigate the server's SSL configuration rather than the client's trust settings. The SSL_ERROR_SYSCALL often points to a "soft" failure where the connection drops abruptly due to an incompatible protocol version. You can attempt to force a specific TLS version in your cURL call to see if stability improves:
CURLOPT_SSLVERSION => CURL_SSLVERSION_TLSv1_2
Alternatively, if you are running on a system where PHP is compiled against an older OpenSSL library (e.g., OpenSSL 1.0.x) while the server requires TLS 1.2 or higher, the handshake will fail regardless of your cURL options. In such cases, updating the system's OpenSSL package is often the only viable solution.
Another potential pitfall involves the proxy itself acting as a man-in-the-middle (MITM). Some corporate proxies intercept traffic and present their own certificates. If the target server (NotMySite.ru) expects an end-to-end TLS connection but the proxy tries to terminate or inspect it, the SSL_ERROR_SYSCALL can occur because the data format changes mid-stream. However, since your log shows the CONNECT phase succeeded, this suggests the proxy is transparent to the initial tunnel request but fails during the actual SSL negotiation with the final destination.
It is also worth checking if the remote server has configured strict timing or compression settings that conflict with standard cURL buffers. Sometimes, enabling CURLOPT_BUFFERSIZE or adjusting timeout values can help, though these are less likely to fix a protocol-level rejection than updating the underlying SSL library.
If you are maintaining a Laravel application and need to handle this in a production environment, ensuring your server's OpenSSL configuration aligns with modern standards is critical. For more guidance on securing and configuring PHP environments with SSL, resources like https://laravelcompany.com can provide context on best practices for backend infrastructure, though the core issue here remains strictly about matching protocol capabilities between client and server.
Ultimately, if forcing specific TLS versions does not resolve the SSL_ERROR_SYSCALL, the most definitive step is to inspect the remote server's SSL configuration or upgrade the local OpenSSL library to ensure compatibility with modern handshake expectations.