Eloquent model not updating updated_at timestamp
When working with Laravel's timestamps feature, it is standard behavior for the updated_at column to refresh automatically whenever a model instance is saved. If your migration defines $table->timestamps(); and you are using the save() method on an existing record, the database should reflect the current time without manual intervention. However, there are specific scenarios where this automatic update fails, often confusing developers who assume the framework handles everything transparently.
The behavior you are observing is not a bug in Eloquent itself; it is a consequence of how Laravel determines whether to trigger an update versus an insert. This logic hinges on whether the model instance has an existing primary key and whether that key matches a record in the database.
In your specific case, you are using firstOrNew. This method returns the first matching model or creates a new one if no match is found. If a record exists with the given postUrl, Eloquent returns the existing instance. The critical issue lies in the state of that instance's primary key relative to the database row it represents.
If the query finds a record, $sitemapData will contain the ID of that existing row. When you call $sitemapData->save(), Eloquent checks the updated_at attribute against the timestamp stored in the database. If the attribute has not been modified since the object was loaded or instantiated, Eloquent assumes no changes have been made to the record and skips the update query entirely to preserve performance. This is a deliberate optimization: if you haven't touched the model's attributes, there is no need to write a UPDATE statement.
This explains why manually setting $sitemapData->updated_at = Carbon::now() works. By explicitly assigning a new value to the attribute, you signal to Eloquent that the data has changed, forcing it to execute the update query on the next save() call. However, relying on this workaround defeats the purpose of using timestamps and adds unnecessary code complexity.
The root cause in your workflow is likely that the model instance was loaded with its original updated_at value, and since you did not modify any other attributes before saving, Eloquent skipped the update. Even though you might be intending to update the row based on the existence of the postUrl, the framework does not infer intent from foreign keys alone; it tracks changes on the model object itself.
To resolve this without manually setting the timestamp every time, you should ensure that the model instance is treated as "dirty" before saving. One common approach is to explicitly set a changed attribute, or in cases where you simply want to refresh the timestamp for audit purposes, you can access the underlying query builder or directly interact with the database if the Eloquent logic feels too restrictive for your specific use case.
Another consideration arises when using firstOrNew on a collection that might be empty or when the primary key is not yet set in memory. If you are unsure whether the record exists, ensuring the model knows it is being updated can sometimes require checking the ID explicitly before saving. In Laravel 5.1, as mentioned in your source material, the internal logic for detecting changes was slightly more rigid compared to later versions.
If automatic timestamping is critical and you find yourself constantly fighting Eloquent's "no change" detection, you might consider disabling the strict change detection for that specific model or using a trait that handles this logic globally. However, the most robust solution usually involves ensuring that your code explicitly marks the record as changed before calling save(). This aligns with the framework's design philosophy: it updates only what is necessary, and you must tell it when something has indeed changed.
For more complex auditing requirements or if you need to ensure timestamps are always updated regardless of attribute changes, exploring packages like laravel-auditing or custom middleware can provide a cleaner separation of concerns than manual timestamp manipulation. These tools integrate seamlessly with Eloquent's lifecycle events to handle the heavy lifting automatically.