How to generate a good salt - Is my function secure enough?

How to generate a good salt - Is my function secure enough?

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 3 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

How to generate a good salt - Is my function secure enough?

The function you are currently using relies on the rand() system call combined with a simple string concatenation loop. While this approach might suffice for non-critical internal identifiers, it is fundamentally insecure for generating cryptographic salts. The primary issue lies in the unpredictability of the random number generator itself.

In PHP, rand() does not use cryptographically secure algorithms by default. It is deterministic and can be predicted if an attacker knows the seed or has access to previous outputs. For a salt, which is the second half of a password hash equation ($Hash = H(Salt + Password)$), predictability is catastrophic. If an attacker can guess the sequence of random numbers your function produces, they can reverse-engineer the salts used for user accounts. This effectively nullifies the security benefit of salting, allowing rainbow tables or pre-computed hashes to become viable again.

Furthermore, the character set you are using—alphanumeric with roughly 62 characters—is acceptable, but it is not optimal. A larger character set increases entropy per byte, making brute-force attacks on the salt value itself more difficult. While a larger subset of characters (including special symbols) is desirable, switching to rand() would still be incorrect regardless of the character universe size because the underlying entropy source remains weak.

The correct approach in PHP is to utilize random_bytes(). This function interfaces directly with the operating system's cryptographically secure pseudo-random number generator (CSPRNG), such as /dev/urandom on Linux or CryptGenRandom on Windows. It returns a string of binary data that is statistically random and unpredictable.

Here is how you should refactor your function:

function generateSecureSalt($length = 32): string {
    $bytes = random_bytes($length);
    return bin2hex($bytes); // Or base64_encode if you prefer a shorter string with higher entropy
}

This implementation generates raw bytes and converts them to hexadecimal. A 32-byte salt results in a 64-character hex string. If you prefer base64 encoding, you can use base64_encode(random_bytes($length)), which produces a more compact string but introduces padding characters that must be stripped during verification.

Regarding your question about expanding the character universe: if you stick to hexadecimal (0-9, A-F), you are limited to 16 bits per byte. Base64 allows for 256 possible values per byte but maps them to a smaller alphabet, effectively reducing the entropy density slightly unless you handle padding carefully. The best practice is often to stick to standard hex or base64url encodings rather than creating custom alphabets with special characters, as this simplifies database storage and comparison logic without sacrificing security.

If you are working within the Laravel ecosystem, you do not need to write this function yourself. The framework provides a built-in RandomStringBuilder class (available in Laravel 7+) or simply relies on random_bytes() directly via helpers like Random::generate(). Using these abstractions ensures consistency and reduces the risk of implementation errors.

Ultimately, the decision to use random_bytes() is non-negotiable for security-sensitive data. There are no easy workarounds or "safe" modes for rand() that developers can toggle on. You must replace the current logic immediately to ensure that your password hashes remain resistant to prediction attacks.

Our network