Private static method vs. static method

Private static method vs. static method

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 3 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

Private Static Method vs. Static Method

In PHP, the static keyword fundamentally changes how a method resolves its context. When you declare a method as static, it bypasses the standard object instantiation process entirely. It allows the method to be invoked directly on the class name, such as ClassName::methodName(). This is useful for utility functions or stateless operations that don't require any instance data.

However, there is often confusion regarding non-static private methods and whether they can exist within a static context. Consider the following example:

class Beer {
    static private $beertype = "IPA";

    private function getBeerType() {
        return self::$beertype;
    }

    static public function BeerInfo() {
        return self::getBeerType();
    }
}

print Beer::BeerInfo() . "\n";

In this scenario, getBeerType() is defined as a non-static private method. The BeerInfo() method is static and calls the private helper. While PHP permits this syntax, it relies on a specific resolution order that many developers find counter-intuitive. When you invoke self::getBeerType() inside a static context, PHP looks for a static version of the method first. If it doesn't find one, it falls back to finding a non-static version and implicitly instantiates the class (or uses the current scope if already instantiated) to call it.

Why Declare Private Methods as Static?

The primary benefit of declaring getBeerType() as static private is explicitness and performance. By making the method static, you signal to the reader and the interpreter that this function operates entirely within the class namespace without needing an object instance. It removes any ambiguity about how the method should be resolved.

Furthermore, strictly speaking, a non-static method implies the potential for accessing $this. Even though self::$beertype accesses a static property, the method signature suggests it could access instance properties or methods. Declaring it as static ensures that only static properties and methods are ever accessed within that scope, preventing accidental reliance on instance state where none exists.

Handling Strict Error Reporting

You noted that with strict error reporting enabled, PHP issues a warning suggesting you should make the method static. This behavior is intentional but nuanced. PHP's engine allows the non-static call to succeed because it can infer that no instance is available and simply uses the class scope to resolve self::. However, this is considered "loose" type checking.

If you want to force an error and prevent execution of code containing non-static methods called from static contexts, you cannot rely solely on runtime warnings. PHP does not provide a native flag to make these calls fatal by default. To enforce this strictness, you must rely on external tools or specific coding standards enforced during the build process rather than runtime configuration.

One approach is to use static analysis tools like PHPStan or Psalm. These tools analyze your codebase before execution and can be configured to treat non-static method calls from static contexts as fatal errors. You can configure phpstan in your project's configuration file to treat these warnings as errors:

// In phpstan.neon
parameters:
  strictTypes: true
  treatUndefinedLikeNonStatic: true # Example of enforcing stricter context rules

Alternatively, if you are working within a Laravel ecosystem, leveraging the LaravelCompany documentation can provide insights into adhering to strict coding standards that might encourage such patterns. While PHP allows flexibility here, adopting a convention where all methods called statically are explicitly declared static aligns with modern best practices for maintainability and clarity.

Conclusion on Best Practices

While PHP permits calling non-static private methods from static public methods without crashing, it is not a robust design pattern. It relies on implicit behavior that can break if the class ever requires instantiation or if you switch to a different runtime environment with stricter settings. The safest and most readable approach is to declare helper methods as static when they are intended to be called statically. This eliminates warnings under strict error reporting and ensures your code remains predictable regardless of future refactoring needs.

Our network