Get all users with role in Laravel

Get all users with role in Laravel

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 3 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

Retrieving Users by Role in Laravel

You are attempting to filter a collection of users based on their associated roles, but your current query returns every user regardless of the Teacher role constraint. The root cause lies in how Eloquent handles relationships combined with conditional logic. In your code snippet, you are using the with() method alongside a closure for eager loading:

$students = User::with(array('Roles' => function($query) {
    $query->where('name', 'Teacher');
}))->get();

This approach tells Eloquent to eagerly load the roles relationship for every user in the collection. However, it does not filter the main query against the related data. The closure inside with() is strictly for optimizing SQL joins and preventing N+1 query problems; it does not act as a scope or condition for the primary query builder instance. Consequently, you get all users, each populated with their roles (or an empty collection if they don't have one), rather than a filtered list of users who actually possess the Teacher role.

To retrieve only the users associated with a specific role, you must modify the primary query to filter against the pivot table or join the necessary tables where the condition resides. Since your schema utilizes an intermediate assigned_roles pivot table, the relationship logic requires careful handling to ensure the where clause targets the correct column.

Using Relationships for Filtering

The most straightforward approach is to leverage the belongsToMany relationship defined in your models. You can attach a constraint directly to the relationship within the query builder before calling get().

Assuming your User model has the following relationship definition:

public function roles()
{
    return $this->belongsToMany('Role', 'assigned_roles');
}

You can retrieve users with a specific role by filtering on the related model's scope or attributes. If you need to filter by the name column of the roles table, you can chain the relationship query:

$teacherUsers = User::with('roles')
    ->whereHas('roles', function ($query) {
        $query->where('name', 'Teacher');
    })
    ->get();

This pattern uses whereHas. It instructs Eloquent to execute a sub-query that checks if the roles relationship contains a record matching your criteria. The resulting collection will only include users who have at least one role named Teacher. If a user has multiple roles, including Teacher, they will be included in the result set.

Handling Multiple Roles or Specific Combinations

If your application logic requires stricter filtering—for instance, ensuring a user has only the Teacher role and no others—you would need to use a different approach involving the pivot table directly or utilizing Eloquent scopes.

For example, using the intermediate assigned_roles table explicitly allows you to query the join condition:

$teacherUsers = User::join('assigned_roles', 'users.id', '=', 'assigned_roles.user_id')
    ->join('roles', 'assigned_roles.role_id', '=', 'roles.id')
    ->where('roles.name', 'Teacher')
    ->get('users.*');

While this SQL approach works, Eloquent's whereHas is generally preferred for readability unless you need to enforce exclusivity (e.g., "only Teacher" vs. "Teacher and Admin"). To achieve the latter with standard Eloquent methods, you often have to query the pivot table or use scopes that handle the exclusion logic.

Model Configuration Considerations

Your source material indicates your models extend ConfideUser and EntrustRole. These are legacy packages (Confide and Entrust) that historically provided helper traits like HasRole. If you are maintaining a legacy codebase, these methods might behave differently than modern Laravel standards. However, the logic for filtering remains consistent: eager loading relationships does not filter the parent query.

If you find yourself dealing with complex role hierarchies or needing to access roles dynamically, consider defining scopes in your Role model that return users filtered by specific names. This keeps your controllers clean and adheres to the Single Responsibility Principle.

For more robust permission handling or if you are migrating away from deprecated packages like Confide/Entrust, reviewing modern authorization packages such as Laravel Spatie's HasRoles trait is often recommended for better maintainability and clearer syntax.

Our network