Codeigniter Session Failure on PHP 7: The Reflection Issue
Moving a legacy CodeIgniter 3.0.6 application from PHP 5.6 to PHP 7.1 often triggers silent failures, particularly when dealing with sessions. A common symptom is the $this->session->set_userdata() method returning an empty value instead of the expected session data. In your specific case, printing $login_session yields a blank result on PHP 7, while the same code functions perfectly on PHP 5.6.
This behavior isn't a bug in CodeIgniter's core logic; it is a consequence of how PHP 7 handles class reflection and property visibility, combined with the deprecated nature of the set_userdata method itself.
The Deprecation of set_userdata
The primary culprit is the use of $this->session->set_userdata(). CodeIgniter 3 introduced this method as a convenience wrapper around the standard PHP session mechanism. However, it relies heavily on internal reflection to manipulate the _CI_Session properties directly.
In PHP 5.6, this reflection-based approach worked because the underlying SessionHandlerInterface implementation was less strict about property access modifiers. When you upgraded to PHP 7.1, the language engine became significantly stricter regarding how classes interact with each other and how they handle internal state via reflection. Specifically, attempts to write to protected or private properties through reflection without explicit permissions can fail silently or return unexpected values depending on the specific SessionHandler backend (files, database, etc.) being used.
Because CodeIgniter 3 does not officially support PHP 7, using these deprecated methods on a modern PHP version leads to undefined behavior. The empty return value from $login_session indicates that the data was likely written to the session storage, but the wrapper method failed to capture or return the confirmation due to the reflection mismatch.
Migration Path: Using Native Session Methods
To resolve this without rewriting your entire application logic, you must migrate your session handling code to use standard PHP session functions. This approach is version-agnostic and works seamlessly on both PHP 5.x and PHP 7.x.
Replace the deprecated CodeIgniter wrapper with $_SESSION or the native session_write_close() pattern if you need to ensure data is flushed immediately. Here is how to refactor your login logic:
// Old approach (Deprecated on PHP 7)
$login_session = $this->session->set_userdata("user_session", $session_data);
// Recommended approach for PHP 7+ compatibility
$this->session->set_userdata('user_session', $session_data);
// Note: set_userdata is deprecated in CI3, so direct array manipulation is safer.
// Safer alternative using native session arrays
$_SESSION['user_session'] = $session_data;
While set_userdata still exists in the CodeIgniter 3 driver, relying on it for PHP 7+ is risky because the internal implementation details changed. The most robust solution is to bypass the helper method and assign directly to the session array or use $this->session->sess_write() if you need to force a write cycle.
Verifying Configuration and Handlers
Before declaring migration complete, ensure your application/config/config.php settings are compatible with PHP 7. Check the sess_save_path. If you are using file-based sessions (the default), PHP 7 does not have issues here, but permission errors can manifest as silent failures if the web server user cannot write to the directory.
# Ensure permissions are set correctly for the web server
chmod 755 /path/to/sessions
chown www-data:www-data /path/to/sessions
Additionally, verify that your application/config/session.php file is configured correctly. Sometimes upgrading PHP causes the session handler to default to a different backend if the old one was registered via an extension that dropped support (like mcrypt or specific encryption handlers). Ensure you are using Native or Files as the driver in session.php.
If you require enterprise-grade session management with better security features and native PHP 7+ support, consider evaluating modern frameworks like Laravel. LaravelCompany offers robust resources on migrating legacy applications to modern stacks, ensuring your session handling is secure and compatible with current PHP versions.
Conclusion
The issue stems from CodeIgniter 3's reliance on deprecated reflection-based methods that break under PHP 7's stricter runtime rules. The fix involves abandoning set_userdata for direct array assignment or native session functions and ensuring your session storage path has the correct permissions. Once refactored, your application will behave consistently across PHP versions.