Laravel lockforupdate (Pessimistic Locking)

Laravel lockforupdate (Pessimistic Locking)

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 5 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

Understanding Laravel's lockForUpdate and Transactional Isolation

When working with Laravel, developers often rely on optimistic locking for concurrency, but there are times when you need strict row-level exclusivity to prevent race conditions. This is where lockForUpdate() comes into play. However, it is a common misconception that this method acts as a global block preventing any other process from touching the row while your transaction is open.

In your specific test case using two browsers—one authenticated and one not—you observed that Browser 2 could still update the row inside the 60-second sleep window of Browser 1. The root cause lies in how InnoDB handles isolation levels and which rows are actually being locked.

The Scope of the Lock

The most critical detail missing from your test is that lockForUpdate() only locks rows that satisfy the query's WHERE clause within the current transaction.

In your code:

$model = \App\Models\User::find(1)->lockForUpdate();
sleep(60);

When Browser 2 hits refresh, it executes a standard query like User::find(1). Even though Browser 1 holds an exclusive lock on the row with ID 1, InnoDB does not automatically block new sessions from reading or writing to that row unless specific isolation levels are in place.

By default, most Laravel applications run at the READ COMMITTED isolation level. At this level, a transaction can read uncommitted changes from other transactions (dirty reads) only if explicitly configured otherwise, but more importantly, it does not automatically prevent other sessions from modifying data that isn't explicitly locked by them in a way that blocks writes.

Wait, that's slightly inaccurate. Let's refine the technical picture. At READ COMMITTED, a session can read data modified by another transaction once that change is committed. However, the real issue here is that Browser 2's query might be failing to see the lock or, more likely, the database engine allows the write because the isolation level doesn't enforce strict locking visibility on new rows being selected without an explicit FOR UPDATE clause on the reading side in some contexts, but primarily, your test setup implies that Browser 2 is running a transaction that does not hold a lock.

Actually, the behavior you saw—where Browser 2 successfully updates the record while Browser 1 sleeps—is a classic symptom of not being inside a consistent isolation level or misunderstanding which rows are locked. If Browser 2 runs outside a transaction or at READ COMMITTED, it might be able to read the row, but can it write?

If your database is set to READ COMMITTED (the default for MySQL), Browser 1 locks the row with FOR UPDATE. This prevents other sessions from modifying that specific row until the transaction of Browser 1 commits or rolls back. If Browser 2 successfully updated the row, one of two things is happening:

  1. The database isolation level is set to something less restrictive than expected (though READ COMMITTED should prevent this).
  2. More likely, Browser 2 is not actually hitting the same row or there is a replication delay issue if you are on a master-slave setup, but assuming a single server, the lock should hold.

However, the most common reason for this "phantom" update behavior in Laravel contexts involves how the model is accessed. If Browser 2 accesses the model via Eager Loading or a different query that doesn't strictly target ID 1 within a transaction, it might bypass the lock. But assuming direct access to ID 1, the lock should persist.

If you are seeing updates succeed during the sleep, check your database configuration in php.ini or .my.cnf. Ensure innodb_lock_wait_timeout isn't causing silent failures, but more importantly, verify the isolation level:

SELECT @@tx_isolation;

If this returns READ-UNCOMMITTED, you will see dirty reads and potentially bypass locks. If it is READ-COMMITTED, writes should be blocked by an exclusive lock held in a transaction.

Shared Lock vs. Exclusive Lock

You also asked about the difference between LOCK IN SHARE MODE (or SELECT ... FOR SHARE) and FOR UPDATE.

  • Shared Lock (SELECT ... FOR SHARE): Allows multiple sessions to read the same row simultaneously but prevents any session from modifying it. This is useful for read-heavy scenarios where you need consistency without exclusive write access.
  • Exclusive Lock (SELECT ... FOR UPDATE): Grants a single session exclusive access to the row, blocking all other reads and writes until the transaction ends.

In your scenario, lockForUpdate() in Laravel translates to an UPDATE statement internally (conceptually) or wraps a SELECT with FOR UPDATE. This acquires an exclusive lock. If Browser 2 can write, it implies either the lock didn't take effect due to isolation levels, or Browser 2 is operating on a different transaction context that allows dirty writes (which shouldn't happen at READ COMMITTED for writes).

Correcting the Test

To properly test this, ensure both browsers are executing their logic inside a database transaction. In Laravel, wrapping your logic in \DB::transaction() is essential. If Browser 2 runs outside a transaction, it commits immediately after the query, releasing any potential locks before they can fully propagate or be observed as blocking.

Revised test for Browser 2:

public function index() {
    return dd(\DB::transaction(function() {
        $model = \App\Models\User::find(1); // No lock here, but it should wait if exclusive lock exists
        $model->point = 999;
        $model->save();
    }));
}

When Browser 1 holds the lock inside its transaction, Browser 2's SELECT or UPDATE will block until Browser 1 commits. You should see the request hang in the browser for the full 60 seconds (plus the time to commit) rather than updating immediately.

If you continue to face issues where the lock appears ineffective, consider checking if you are using a shared host database connection pool that might be isolating connections incorrectly, though this is rare with standard InnoDB setups. Always ensure your application runs at READ COMMITTED isolation level for these locking behaviors to function as documented in the Laravel documentation.

Our network