JSON_ENCODE for multidimensional array giving different results
In PHP, the behavior of json_encode depends entirely on the internal structure of the data you are serializing. When working with multidimensional arrays, it is easy to assume that a list of elements will always serialize to a JSON array ([...]). However, assigning a key to an element fundamentally changes the data type from a "list" to an "associative object," which alters the output structure significantly.
Consider the first scenario where you construct an array using positional indices only:
$arrytest = array(
array('a' => 1, 'b' => 2),
array('c' => 3),
array('d' => 4)
);
In this specific implementation, PHP treats $arrytest as a standard indexed array. The first element is at index 0, the second at 1, and so on. When json_encode processes this structure, it recognizes that every top-level element is itself an array. Consequently, it serializes the container as a JSON array containing multiple JSON objects:
[{"a":1,"b":2},{"c":3},{"d":4}]
This is the expected behavior for representing a collection or list of items where order matters and no specific names are attached to the items themselves.
Now, look at what happens when you assign a string key directly to one of those inner arrays:
$arrytest = array(
array('a' => 1, 'b' => 2),
"secondarray" => array('c' => 3),
array('d' => 4)
);
By explicitly defining the middle element with the key "secondarray", you have transformed the top-level structure into an associative array. While PHP arrays can be mixed (containing both indexed and associative entries), json_encode follows a strict rule: if an outer array contains any string keys, it is serialized as a JSON object ({}), not a JSON array.
The resulting output reflects this structural shift:
{"0":{"a":1,"b":2},"secondarray":{"c":3},"1":{"d":4}}
Notice how the keys "0" and "1" appear alongside the named key "secondarray". This confirms that the top-level container is now an object. The values inside are still arrays, so they serialize as objects within the main JSON object.
Why does this happen?
The core distinction lies in the definition of a list versus an associative map. In JSON, an array implies an ordered sequence where indices are implicit (0, 1, 2). An object implies a collection of named properties.
When you write array('key' => 'value') or $arr['key'] = 'value', you are declaring that this entry has a specific identity. Even if the rest of the array remains purely indexed, the presence of that single named property forces the entire parent structure to become an object during serialization.
This is often a source of confusion when migrating from PHP's flexible array syntax to strict JSON standards. In many cases, developers want a clean list output like [...] but accidentally introduce string keys while building the data structure in memory. For instance, using array_combine or iterating with foreach where $key becomes a string can inadvertently create this mixed-type scenario.
Practical Implications and Trade-offs
Understanding this behavior is crucial when designing APIs. If you are returning a list of resources to a frontend application, ensuring your PHP data structure remains purely indexed prevents the API from accidentally returning an object. An object implies that the client should treat the keys as properties, potentially leading to issues if the client expects positional access or if it iterates over the list assuming numeric keys.
Conversely, there are valid use cases for mixed arrays. If you need to return a structure where some items have generic names (like 0 and 1) but others require specific identification (like "user_id" or "metadata"), mixing types allows you to encode that hierarchy in a single pass. However, this comes at the cost of losing the semantic distinction between a "list" and a "map."
If you require a strict JSON array output regardless of how the data was constructed in PHP, you must ensure no string keys exist at the top level. A common pattern to enforce this is using array_values() before encoding:
$cleaned_data = array_values($arrytest);
$json_output = json_encode($cleaned_data);
This strips all string keys, forcing PHP to treat the collection as an indexed list again. However, you must be aware that this operation discards the named properties entirely. If the data inside the sub-arrays relies on those top-level names for context, array_values will break your data integrity.
Conclusion
The discrepancy in output stems from a fundamental difference in data structure: one is an indexed list, and the other is an associative map. json_encode faithfully represents this structural difference by choosing between JSON arrays and JSON objects. To maintain consistent output, you must control whether string keys exist at the top level of your multidimensional array, or explicitly strip them if a list format is required.