Laravel get a collection of relationship items

Laravel get a collection of relationship items

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 3 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

Laravel get a collection of relationship items

When you have a polymorphic or nested relationship chain like User → Shops → Products, it is common to end up with data structures that are slightly too nested for your specific view logic. In the scenario where you want all products for a certain user, you might initially write something like this:

Auth::user()->shops()->with('products')->get();

This approach works perfectly fine if you want to iterate over shops and then their products in a nested loop. However, if your goal is to retrieve only a flat Collection of Product models, adding .select('products.*') inside the query builder chain often breaks the logic. The issue stems from how Laravel handles eager loading and the scope of the select clause when applied to a parent model's relationship collection rather than the relationship itself.

The core problem is that calling .select() on the collection returned by the first query (the shops) does not automatically propagate into the sub-query for the eager-loaded relationships unless explicitly told to do so via the with method's scope or by modifying the underlying SQL joins. When you attempt to filter fields using .select('products.*'), Laravel may interpret this in the context of the Shops query, resulting in a malformed SQL statement that either throws an error or returns incomplete data because the products table isn't directly accessible in that specific query context without proper joining logic.

To correctly extract a flat collection of products from this nested relationship structure, you need to ensure that the eager loading happens first and then map the results into a new collection. One robust way to achieve this is by using the loadManyToMany or simply iterating through the relationship while flattening the result set:

$products = Auth::user()->shops()
    ->with('products')
    ->get()
    ->flatMap(function ($shop) {
        return $shop->products;
    });

This code retrieves all shops with their associated products eagerly loaded, then uses flatMap to merge the nested collections into a single flat collection of Product models. This preserves the relationship data (like the parent shop if needed) without duplicating columns unnecessarily.

If you specifically need only the product attributes and not the relationship metadata, you can further manipulate the collection:

$products = Auth::user()->shops()
    ->with('products')
    ->get()
    ->flatMap(function ($shop) {
        return $shop->products;
    })
    ->map(function ($product) {
        $product->unsetRelation('shop');
        return $product;
    });

This approach ensures you have a clean collection of products ready for serialization or API response formatting. It avoids the pitfall of trying to use .select() incorrectly on the parent relationship chain, which can lead to ambiguous SQL queries or unintended data loss.

In production environments, always consider whether you truly need to eager load the entire nested structure before flattening it. If performance is a concern with large datasets, ensure that your database indexes are optimized for the foreign keys involved in the User → Shop and Shop → Product relationships. Additionally, be mindful of N+1 query issues if you attempt to access relationship data outside the eager-loaded scope after flattening.

For further reading on advanced relationship handling and collection manipulation in Laravel, you can explore resources like https://laravelcompany.com, which often provides community-driven insights into optimizing Eloquent queries for complex domain models.

Our network