Debugging Deeply Nested Laravel Relationships
When you need to fetch an Event and include all associated Person records, the default Eloquent relationship chain often feels insufficient if your database schema has multiple intermediate tables. In your specific case, the path from an event to a person isn't direct; it flows through City, Company, and an intersection table (event_scores) that defines the subscription with a pivot score.
The SQL query you provided works perfectly because it explicitly joins these tables:
SELECT persons.id, persons.firstname, persons.lastname, event_scores.score
FROM events
JOIN cities ON cities.id = events.city_id
JOIN companies ON cities.id = companies.city_id
JOIN persons ON companies.id = persons.company_id
JOIN event_scores ON event_scores.person_id = persons.id
WHERE event_scores.event_id = 1
GROUP BY persons.id
However, translating this into a clean Eloquent query requires more than just stacking eager loading methods like with('city'). The issue lies in how the relationships are defined and how the pivot table is handled across multiple joins.
Mapping the Relationship Chain
Your models establish a hierarchy: an Event belongs to a City, which has many Companys, and each Company has many Persons. The link between the person and the event itself is stored in the event_scores table via a many-to-many relationship on the Person model.
The primary challenge here is that standard eager loading (Event::with('city')) only fetches immediate children. It does not traverse the chain to the grand-grandchildren, nor does it automatically handle the specific join conditions required to filter by the event_scores pivot data while simultaneously selecting person details.
Handling the Pivot in Nested Queries
The most robust way to achieve this without writing raw SQL is to leverage the relationship defined on the model that owns the pivot tableâin this case, the Person model. Since the Person model defines a belongsToMany('Event', 'event_scores'...) relationship, you can traverse back up the chain from the person.
You cannot simply call $event->persons() because that relationship doesn't exist on the Event model in your current setup. Instead, you must construct a query that joins the necessary tables and then uses the relationship to filter or select data.
One effective approach is to start with the Person model (or use a raw join) and eagerly load the event details from there, effectively reversing the traversal direction for the scope of the query:
$persons = Person::join('event_scores', 'persons.id', '=', 'event_scores.person_id')
->join('companies', 'persons.company_id', '=', 'companies.id')
->join('cities', 'companies.city_id', '=', 'cities.id')
->join('events', 'cities.id', '=', 'events.city_id')
->where('event_scores.event_id', $eventId)
->select('persons.*', 'event_scores.score')
->get();
This query mimics your SQL logic but keeps the results in an Eloquent collection where you can access $person->score and $person->company. If you strictly need to start from the Event model, you will likely have to use a custom scope or a raw query within the event controller to join these tables and then map the results.
The Limitation of Standard Eager Loading
A common mistake developers make is assuming that chaining with() calls can traverse arbitrary depths regardless of relationship definitions. While you can do $event->load(['city.companies.persons']), this only works if the foreign key constraints align perfectly and if you aren't filtering by data stored in a pivot table (like the score).
When a filter condition exists on a pivot column (e.g., WHERE event_scores.event_id = 1), standard eager loading often fails to apply that constraint correctly across multiple levels unless the relationship is explicitly defined with the correct intermediate keys. Eloquent's query builder handles single-level pivots well, but multi-table joins with specific pivot filters often require explicit join() statements or a raw query wrapper to ensure the event_scores table is included in the scope of the eager load.
Conclusion on Implementation
For deeply nested relationships involving pivot tables, relying solely on Eloquent's built-in relationship magic can be limiting. If you find yourself writing complex joins just to fetch a list of subscribers, it is often more maintainable to define a custom scope or a query method that encapsulates the join logic. This keeps your controllers clean and ensures that the specific filtering requirements of your pivot table are handled explicitly rather than implicitly.
