How to Save in a Polymorphic Many-to-Many Relationship
Defining polymorphic many-to-many relationships in Laravel is often straightforward, but the mechanics of persisting data through them can be tricky. The standard pattern involves using morphToMany on the parent model and morphedByMany on the child. You might define a relationship like this:
class Post extends Model
{
public function tags()
{
return $this->morphToMany('App\Tag', 'taggable');
}
}
And on the Tag model, you would typically see multiple accessors for different types of content:
class Tag extends Model
{
public function posts()
{
return $this->morphedByMany('App\Post', 'taggable');
}
public function videos()
{
return $this->morphedByMany('App\Video', 'taggable');
}
}
The confusion usually arises when you try to attach a record. The most intuitive attempt looks like this:
$tag = Tag::find(1);
$video = Video::find(1);
$tag->videos()->associate($video);
Or perhaps using sync:
$tag->videos()->sync([$video]);
These approaches fail because they misunderstand how polymorphic many-to-many relationships store data. In a standard many-to-many relationship, the pivot table connects two specific models directly. However, in a polymorphic setup, the "pivot" is actually a single table that must store three pieces of information: the ID of the tag, the ID of the related model (whether it's a Post or Video), and a type discriminator to tell you which model it is.
Laravel does not automatically know that $video belongs in the videos column when you call associate() on the videos relationship. The associate() method is designed primarily for one-to-one relationships where the foreign key name matches the relationship name. For many-to-many relationships, even polymorphic ones, Laravel expects you to manipulate the underlying collection or pivot table directly.
To attach a video to a tag using the videos relationship on the Tag model, you must use the attach() method. The signature requires both the model instance and the type string:
$tag->videos()->attach($video->id, ['type' => 'Video']);
However, there is a critical detail regarding the morph_type column in your database migration. When you define the relationship with 'App\Tag', 'taggable', Laravel expects the pivot table to have a taggable_id and a taggable_type. The type passed to attach() must match the model name exactly as stored, or you must ensure your migration defines the column correctly.
In many real-world scenarios, developers prefer to pass the model instance directly to attach(), but with polymorphic relationships, you often need to explicitly provide the morph_type if you aren't using the default inference logic strictly tied to the relationship name. A more robust approach involves attaching via the pivot table or ensuring the type is inferred correctly by passing the full model class name in some versions, though typically just the ID and the correct type string works if the migration matches.
If you are managing the entire list of related items at once, sync() is still available but requires careful handling:
$tag->videos()->sync([
1 => ['type' => 'Video'], // ID => [attributes]
]);
Note that sync() will delete all existing video associations for that tag and replace them with the new ones. This is destructive; use it only when you intend to reset the collection. If you need to preserve existing videos while adding a new one, stick with attach().
The underlying mechanism relies on your migration file defining the pivot table correctly. You should ensure the column names match the morph_to and morph_type expectations defined in your relationship methods. If you define the relationship as morphToMany('App\Tag', 'taggable'), the pivot table must have columns named tag_id, taggable_id, and taggable_type.
Laravel's flexibility here allows for dynamic typing, but it demands precision when persisting data. Always verify that your database schema aligns with the relationship definitions to avoid silent failures where the association appears to be made but is actually stored incorrectly or throws a type mismatch error upon retrieval.
