Best way to initialize an (empty) array in PHP
In ActionScript 3 and a few other languages, developers often prefer var foo = [] over new Array() because the former creates a primitive-like structure while the latter instantiates a full object with potential overhead. The question naturally arises: does this distinction hold any weight in modern PHP?
The short answer is that for standard PHP 7 and later versions, there is no meaningful performance difference between using the shorthand syntax ([]) and the traditional array() function or even the new Array() constructor (though the latter is rarely used). However, understanding why these differences exist in other languages helps clarify what you can ignore in PHP.
The Evolution of Syntax
In ActionScript, the array literal syntax [] was distinct from the constructor new Array(). The literal created a dense array with no properties, whereas the constructor could be used to create sparse arrays or objects depending on arguments. In PHP, the story is simpler but evolved through significant versions.
Prior to PHP 5.4, there were two primary ways to declare an empty array:
$arr = array();
// or
$arr = new Array(); // Technically valid but not idiomatic
The array() function was always a constructor call that returned a resource (in older versions) or a value. While function calls do have a slight overhead compared to operator evaluation, the engine optimizations in PHP 5.4 introduced the short array syntax []. This removed the need for any function call entirely, but the resulting internal representation is identical whether you used array(), new Array(), or [].
Performance Considerations
If you are initializing an empty array inside a class property definition, such as:
class Foo {
private $arr = [];
}
Using [] is the standard, idiomatic choice. It is concise and readable. The performance gain from avoiding a function call is negligible in this context because the overhead of object instantiation (new Foo()) dwarfs the cost of initializing an empty array.
Benchmarking tools like Xdebug's profiling or Blackfire would show that the time spent calling array() versus evaluating [] is measured in microseconds, and usually falls within the noise floor of other execution costs. The memory footprint is also identical; both result in a standard "empty" internal array structure with zero elements.
When Syntax Choice Might Matter
The only scenario where syntax choice becomes slightly more relevant is when readability dictates the approach. If you are initializing an array with default values, [] allows for immediate expansion:
// Defining defaults directly
$config = [
'debug' => true,
];
Using array() here can feel like it introduces unnecessary verbosity. Furthermore, if you need to create an object that behaves differently from a standard array (e.g., a sparse array in very old PHP versions), new Array() might have been necessary, but that capability was removed or deprecated long ago. Modern PHP arrays are always dense, zero-indexed, and behave consistently regardless of how they were initialized.
The Laravel Ecosystem Context
If you are working within the Laravel framework, you will almost exclusively encounter the short array syntax []. Laravel's collection methods and configuration systems rely on standard PHP arrays. While Laravel does not provide a specific utility to optimize array initialization beyond standard PHP features, adhering to the [] syntax aligns with the broader ecosystem conventions.
There is no hidden API or configuration option in Laravel that changes how empty arrays are handled internally. The engine manages these details efficiently regardless of the source code style. If you find yourself using array() frequently in a Laravel project, it might be worth reviewing whether that specific line adds clarity or simply adheres to legacy habits.
Final Recommendation
For 99% of use cases in PHP 7 and above, initializing an empty array with [] is the preferred method. It offers identical performance characteristics to array() and avoids any confusion regarding function calls. The only reason to stick with array() would be if you are maintaining legacy codebases that predate PHP 5.4 and lack a clear migration path, but even then, refactoring to the short syntax is generally safe and recommended for consistency.
