Laravel how to add a custom function in an Eloquent model?

Laravel how to add a custom function in an Eloquent model?

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 3 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

Accessing Custom Methods on Eloquent Models Without Method Chaining

When extending an Eloquent model, it is easy to confuse standard accessor patterns with relationship definitions. You might want to define a helper method that calculates a value—like the lowest price from a collection of child records—and then access it directly after retrieving a model instance. In your specific case, you defined lowest() in the Product model to return the minimum price from the related Price models:

public function lowest()
{
    return $this->prices->min('price');
}

This works perfectly when called with parentheses: Product::find(1)->lowest(). However, removing the parentheses results in an error: Relationship method must return an object of type Illuminate\Database\Eloquent\Relations\Relation. This happens because Laravel treats any method named has* or methods that follow specific naming conventions as potential relationship definitions, but more critically, Eloquent reserves the ability to chain relationships for query building.

The root cause lies in how Eloquent resolves properties on a model instance. When you access $model->lowest, Eloquent does not immediately call the method. Instead, it checks if lowest is defined as a relationship. Since your method name doesn't strictly violate the "has" prefix rule, but rather conflicts with the expectation that public methods returning collections or relations are relationships, Laravel's magic getter logic gets confused if the return type isn't explicitly handled as a non-relationship property.

Actually, the specific error message you received indicates that Eloquent is attempting to treat your lowest method as a relationship accessor. This often happens when the method name mimics relationship syntax or when the framework tries to resolve it through the dynamic relationship resolver before falling back to standard method calls. To make $model->lowest work without parentheses, you need to ensure Laravel recognizes it as a simple property access that returns a scalar value, not a relationship.

One reliable approach is to use an accessor instead of a regular method. Accessors are specifically designed for this purpose: they allow you to define how a model attribute should be accessed when the property name matches the accessor's base name. By renaming your method to follow the getLowestAttribute convention, you can access it as a property:

use Illuminate\Database\Eloquent\Model;

class Product extends Model
{
    public function getLowestAttribute($value)
    {
        return $this->prices->min('price');
    }
}

With this implementation, you can now retrieve the value using Product::find(1)->lowest. The framework will automatically invoke getLowestAttribute and return the result as a simple property. This pattern is standard for returning scalar values from models without implying a relationship exists.

There are trade-offs to consider here. If you use a custom method named simply lowest, it remains callable as a function (->lowest()), but accessing it as a property (->lowest) requires the accessor naming convention. Mixing these patterns can lead to confusion in codebases where some developers expect methods and others expect properties. Using accessors for computed fields keeps the distinction clear: relationships are defined via relationName(), while computed values should use getRelationAttributeNameAttribute.

Another option is to avoid the ambiguity entirely by using a direct property definition if the value can be cached or recalculated efficiently, though that changes how the data is stored. For dynamic calculations like aggregating prices from a relationship, accessors are the cleanest solution. They keep the logic within the model without requiring controller-side handling or query modification.

If you prefer to stick with your original method name, ensure you do not try to access it as a property unless you rename the method to follow Laravel's accessor conventions. This distinction prevents runtime errors and ensures your code remains robust when interacting with Eloquent's relationship system.

Our network