PHP: merge two arrays while keeping keys instead of reindexing?
When you pass two arrays to array_merge, the function behaves exactly as its name suggests: it merges them by value, but it does so by re-indexing numeric keys into a continuous sequence starting from zero. This is problematic when your second array contains integer keys that must be preserved alongside string keys.
In your specific case, $staticIdentifications uses string keys (like Users::userID), while $companyVarIdentifications relies on integer IDs returned by CompanyVars::getIdentificationVarsFriendly. If you run array_merge on these, PHP will sequentially reassign the integer keys from the second array as if they were part of a single numeric list. This destroys the association between those integer IDs and their corresponding values.
The core issue lies in how PHP treats numeric keys during an associative merge. When mixing string and integer keys, array_merge attempts to create a contiguous numeric index for all elements, effectively discarding the original integer keys from the second array. To preserve them, you need to bypass the automatic re-indexing behavior entirely.
The most direct solution is to use the + operator instead of array_merge. This operator concatenates arrays without altering their internal structures or reindexing keys. It treats the right-hand side as a distinct block of data that retains its original key associations.
$idVars = $staticIdentifications + $companyVarIdentifications;
This approach ensures that every integer key in $companyVarIdentifications remains untouched, coexisting seamlessly with the string keys from $staticIdentifications. The resulting array will be a true associative collection where 0 might map to a static user ID, while 12345 maps directly to a dynamic company variable without any intermediate renumbering.
If you are working in a Laravel environment, this technique is particularly useful when building query scopes or defining column mappings that depend on specific numeric identifiers from external sources. For instance, if you are constructing a complex Eloquent query where certain columns must be mapped to specific database fields using integer offsets derived from a company configuration, maintaining those exact keys is critical for the ORM to execute correctly.
There is a subtle trade-off to consider with the + operator compared to array_merge. While array_merge throws an error if keys overlap, the + operator silently overwrites values in the left-hand array with duplicates from the right-hand array. In your scenario, since the source material explicitly states that neither array will ever have overlapping keys, this behavior is not a risk. However, it is worth noting that relying on this silence can sometimes mask bugs if key management becomes less strict in future iterations of the codebase.
Another consideration involves the order of operations. Since + concatenates arrays, the elements from $staticIdentifications appear first, followed by those from $companyVarIdentifications. If your application logic depends on a specific ordering of these identifiers, you must ensure that this sequence aligns with your expectations. Unlike array_merge, which might sort or reorganize data based on key types, + strictly preserves the relative order and integrity of the input arrays.
If you ever find yourself needing to merge multiple arrays in a chain while preserving all keys, you can simply chain the + operator: $a + $b + $c. This pattern scales well for combining static configurations with dynamic payloads without ever triggering unwanted re-indexing. Just remember that if any of those arrays contain overlapping keys, the rightmost value will win silently, so ensuring unique keys remains your primary responsibility.
