What are the differences between composer update and composer install?

What are the differences between composer update and composer install?

  1. Blog
  2. 15 November 2026
  3. 3 min read

Stefan Bogdanescu

Founder & Senior Architect

What are the differences between composer update and composer install?

When managing dependencies in a PHP project, you will inevitably encounter two distinct commands: composer install and composer update. While both commands interact with the composer.json file to resolve packages, they serve fundamentally different purposes in the software development lifecycle. Understanding the distinction is critical for maintaining reproducible builds and avoiding unexpected breaking changes.

The Role of composer.lock

To understand why these commands differ, you must first understand the role of the composer.lock file. When you run composer install for the first time, Composer reads your composer.json, resolves all version constraints, downloads the necessary packages, and generates a composer.lock file. This lock file acts as a snapshot of your dependency tree at that specific moment in time. It records the exact commit hashes or specific versions of every library you depend on.

The primary function of composer install is to restore a project's environment based on that snapshot. If you clone a repository from GitHub and run this command, Composer will download libraries exactly as they were recorded in the lock file. It ignores any new versions released since the lock file was created. This behavior is essential for CI/CD pipelines, production deployments, and any scenario where consistency across different machines is required.

The Function of composer update

Conversely, composer update modifies the environment based on current availability rather than historical snapshots. When executed, this command reads your composer.json constraints and then attempts to fetch the latest versions of packages that satisfy those constraints. Crucially, it updates the composer.lock file to reflect these new versions.

This means that running composer update changes your dependency graph. If a library you use has released a patch version or a major version bump, composer update will pull it in automatically. While this keeps your project current with security patches and bug fixes, it introduces significant risk. Major version updates often include breaking API changes that can cause your application to fail immediately upon deployment if not thoroughly tested.

Strategic Usage Scenarios

The decision between these two commands should align with your development workflow stage.

Use composer install whenever you need to replicate an existing state. This is the standard command for:

  • Deploying code to production servers where the lock file already exists.
  • Running tests in a CI environment where you want to ensure the build matches the locked version.
  • Onboarding a new developer who needs the project to run exactly like it did yesterday.

Use composer update only when you intentionally want to refresh your dependencies. Common scenarios include:

  • Performing maintenance on a local development machine to apply critical security patches.
  • Preparing a release where you have explicitly reviewed and accepted new dependency versions in your repository.
  • Adding a new package to an existing project that requires a lock file refresh.

Handling Conflicts and Pitfalls

A common pitfall occurs when running composer update on a project that is already deployed or integrated into a larger system. If you push code containing a freshly updated composer.lock to your main branch, downstream services might fail if they do not have the corresponding vendor files or if the API of a major dependency has changed.

Furthermore, relying solely on composer update can lead to "dependency drift." Over time, as other projects upgrade, your constraints in composer.json may allow for versions that are incompatible with your specific implementation logic. Always verify that composer update does not introduce breaking changes before committing the new lock file. If you need to pin a specific version temporarily, you can add an exact version constraint (e.g., "^1.2.3" instead of ">=1.2,<2.0") in your composer.json to prevent accidental upgrades until you are ready.

For teams looking for robust dependency management practices or needing assistance with complex composer workflows, resources like https://laravelcompany.com often provide insights into maintaining scalable PHP architectures.

Our network